Why Blending a Family Too Quickly Can Backfire: Hidden Anxiety Behind Stepfamily Conflict

Tuesday Series:

When two people fall in love, it is understandable that they want their families to come together. There may be excitement about a new home, shared holidays, family dinners and finally having the family life everyone has been hoping for.

But there is something important I want couples to understand before they start blending their families: falling in love with someone does not mean your children are ready to become a family with them.

Two adults can become very attached, very quickly. They may feel certain they have found their person, they want to be around them all the time, and they want to build a shared life immediately.  I was reading a book recently that talked about a Velcro marriage and a peel-and-stick family.  I hadn’t heard those terms before but they resonated. Some adults really feel the need to be always close and always with their partners.  When parents have this kind of relationship with new partners — and sometimes a few — after a divorce or death of a spouse, it’s easy to want everyone else on board, and hard to remember that children are not necessarily experiencing the same enthusiasm, security or readiness.

A new relationship may represent hope for the adults. For children, divorce or death represents loss, and quick closeness or forced closeness can represent another loss, another change, and another relationship they didn’t choose.

Why stepfamilies or blended families need more time than couples expect

Researcher Patricia Papernow has spent decades studying stepfamily relationships. Her work highlights something that can be reassuring for families: stepfamilies have a different developmental structure from first families. They are not simply first families with additional people.  They are two different families.

Children already have established relationships, histories, routines and loyalties. They may be moving between two households, navigating a parent’s new relationship, or still grieving the original family structure. Some may be hoping their parents will reunite, even years after separation.

The American Psychological Association also emphasizes the importance of allowing relationships between stepparents and children to develop gradually.

A four-year-old, a ten-year-old, a thirteen-year-old, and a seventeen-year-old are not experiencing the same transition.

Younger children may struggle with sharing a parent’s attention and may interpret changes in routines as threats to their security. School-aged children may be more aware of the implications of divorce and remarriage, including loyalty conflicts. Adolescents are working toward independence and may experience expectations of instant family closeness as an intrusion into their developing identity.

And sometimes the child who appears to be doing perfectly well is the one managing the most anxiety.

When family anxiety becomes relationship conflict

Consider a composite example from the kinds of situations I encounter.

A father moves in with his new partner. She is enthusiastic about creating family traditions and wants everyone to participate. His son or daughter becomes withdrawn, increasingly irritable and reluctant to join family activities.

The new partner feels rejected. The father feels guilty and scared. He may start pressuring his daughter to get on board. He may also start avoiding conversations that might upset either person. Eventually, the stepparent feels unsupported and unappreciated, the father feels criticized, and the son or daughter becomes the apparent source of the family’s problems.

But is the son or daughter really the problem?

Or might their behaviour be communicating something the adults haven’t yet made room to understand?

Perhaps a daughter misses having her father to herself. Perhaps she feels disloyal to her mother. Perhaps this change in tradition is happening too fast, or represents an additional loss she can’t express (or maybe she can), perhaps she feels uncomfortable with stepsiblings that don’t feel like family at all. Perhaps she is worried that another adult relationship will change her place in the family.  A son may have different dynamics entirely though the research often demonstrates trends down gender lines.

The answer matters because treating anxiety as defiance can create more of the very conflict everyone is trying to prevent.

Why “slow-cooking” a stepfamily matters

In my work with couples and families, I pay attention to what is happening underneath behaviour, not simply what people are doing on the surface.  Ron Deal, a Christian and faith based author, therapist and stepfamily expert, provides some agnostic advice about high heat and burn or blend, versus the “slow cooker” approach to forming a stepfamily.  In my practice, many couples come feeling the house is already “on fire” as it were, and that makes the idea of slowing down challenging.

This go slow approach includes paying attention to a few different areas.  For instance, it could mean  working on strengthening the couple’s attachment bond, parenting differences, previous relationship injuries, grief, guilt and expectations about what a successful family should look like.

Sometimes the adults need help tolerating the fact that their children don’t feel the same way they do. Sometimes a stepparent needs support with feelings of rejection or exclusion. Sometimes a biological parent needs to become more comfortable setting boundaries with their partner while remaining emotionally available to their child.

This is not about asking adults to sacrifice their relationship. It is about building one that can accommodate the developmental and emotional realities of the children involved, while also giving the children boundaries and a set of expectations.

Preventing tomorrow’s conflict starts today

I see part of my role as helping families prevent pathways to conflict that can become entrenched over time and lead to more distant relationships in adulthood. I also work with families where damage has already occurred and resentment, anxiety or estrangement has begun to take hold.

Sometimes the most important work is slowing down, acknowledging what has been lost, and becoming curious about what each person is experiencing. It’s important to remember that stepfamilies are formed out of loss.  That can be tough to swallow when couples fall in love again.

I help blended families understand that not every family will become especially close. That doesn’t mean it has failed.  They are all different.

A healthier goal is a family where people can feel respected, secure and connected without being forced into relationships or roles they are not ready for.

That is a much stronger foundation than simply trying to blend everyone together.

Why Seek Stepparent and Blended Family Therapy in Hamilton?

In Hamilton and throughout Ontario, blended families are becoming increasingly common. Many couples and stepparents find themselves struggling with issues that are unique to stepfamily life and that are not addressed with traditional family therapy. Therapy for families or blended families, whether new or more advanced, may provide a supportive space to address these challenges before they erode relationships or create lasting resentment.

Whether you’re in Hamilton, Stoney Creek, Burlington, Dundas, Ancaster, or anywhere across Ontario, I offer in-person blended family therapy in Hamilton, and online family and stepfamily therapy in Toronto and across Ontario. I am also starting to grow my team to better serve the demand for help.


Taking the Next Step

If your attempts to blend your stepfamily are leaving you feeling anxious, worried, or depressed, and you want therapy just for yourself, for you as a couple, or your family and other relationships, please know you don’t have to struggle alone. With the right tools, insight, education, and guidance, you can manage expectations, reduce conflict, strengthen your couple bond, and create a family system that works better for everyone.

Reach out for a free 15 minute phone consultation and let’s see if we are a fit.

 Following a consult or therapy: Because psychotherapy (and even the consult) is confidential, therapists are prevented from responding to public comments or reviews. If someone has concerns about an interaction with me and my practice, I encourage reaching out directly so concerns can be addressed respectfully and privately whenever possible.

Professional Endorsements and Verified Client Feedback are available on Luminos and Psychology Today

“Therapy isn’t about perfect people giving perfect advice.  It’s about two or more humans trying to understand something difficult together”

Please see:

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes and is not a substitute for therapy or individualized mental health care.

#BlendedFamilyTherapy, #StepfamilyCounselling, #Stepparenting, #FamilyTherapy, #ParentingAfterDivorce, #HamiltonTherapist, #OntarioPsychotherapy

 

Please follow and like us: